| 2025 | Seamen | Puffin Gesserit (Puffin Gesserit 🐧🪬) | The Yorkshire Puddings | Standard Deviations |
| 2024 | Kurlewless (Kurlewis) | The Puffins (Puffin Gesserit 🐧🪬) | SERPION recalled | Unknown |
| 2023 | AT Football Team (A&T Football) | The Fresno Fishies (The Fishies) | The Dirty Birds recalled | Unknown |
| 2022 | SERPION | Kurlewless (Kurlewis) | The Beer Barons (Beer Barons) recalled | Unknown |
| 2021 | Leeannacondas | The Hatters | Swiftboats 4 breakdown justice (London Tanqs) or The Dirty Birds Disputed | Unknown |
| 2020 | Burnmore Dynamics (Burnaise Dynamics) | SERPION | Mikkels Manatees | Unknown |
| 2019 | [name redacted] (Burnaise Dynamics) | Peaches and Kareem (Not enough cooks) | Chicken Karama with rice (Mooreccan chicken with rice) recalled | Unknown |
| 2018 | L'Ebron James (Puffin Gesserit 🐧🪬) | The Ertz Lockett (The Hatters) | Wake up Mr Freeman (Mikkels Manatees) | Unknown |
| 2017 | The Adams Family (London Tanqs) | Ring my Bell (Burnaise Dynamics) | Kandys Konservatives (A&T Football) | Unknown |
| 2016 | Can we Fitz it- yes we Charcan (The Hatters) | SERPION | Thomas the Tank Engine (Kurlewis) | Unknown |
| 2015 | One Rush to Rule Jamaal (Mooreccan chicken with rice) | Le'Veon a prayer (The Hatters) | The Sinking Ship (The Dirty Birds) | Unknown |
| 2014 | SERPION | IT'S ON LIKE NDAMUKONG (Puffin Gesserit 🐧🪬) | Doug and the Staff Infections (Burnaise Dynamics) | |
| 2013 | DeMarco Polo (Puffin Gesserit 🐧🪬) | The Alligators (The Aligators) | Jordy Shore (London Tanqs) | |
| 2012 | It's a Brees (Beer Barons) | The Claireville Cougars | Fifty Shades of Ray (Mikkels Manatees) | |